That however hasn't been the case for almost a year now as nothing new has been able to demote the love I have for my current handset, the Samsung Galaxy S3. I simply cannot fault it and until now, no new phone has been able to beat it. My dilemma now though is that with all the recent announcements at CES and Mobile World Congress, there isn't just one device that's been pulling my attention from my beloved S3, not two either, but three.
I'm currently tied between choosing the Sony Xperia Z, the HTC One, or the as of yet unannounced Samsung Galaxy S4 to be my next handset. The contest is slightly unfair at the moment seeing as all of the information about the S4 is just rumour and Samsung have yet to release anything official but seeing as most of the leaks and rumours about the S2 and S3 came to be true, I'm holding them with at least few pinches of salt for the purposes of this blog post.
In true teenage girl style, I decided to make a pro/con list to settle my indecisions and come to a conclusion, so here goes...
Sony Xperia Z
Pros:
- Incredible design, one of the best looking phones I have ever seen and I personally think it looks far better than the other two (if rumoured images of the S4 come to be real).
- Water proof and dust proof with an IP57 rating. This is just unheard of in premium devices and just adds a greater piece of mind when using it around rain or water. I have even seen videos on YouTube where people have used it as an underwater video camera with incredible results.
- SD Card slot, which is a necessity for me, I have a lot of data, and having it on removable media makes it far easier to transfer that data between devices.
- Bravia display engine that makes photos and videos look absolutely stunning.
- A 13 mega pixel camera to keep the photographer in me happy, with Sony's Exmor Sensor and a world first with HDR video.
- It will work better with my Sony SmartWatch, which works great with any Android device, but the call features work best with a Sony phone.
- Another world first with a full 1080p HD screen, great for web browsing and videos which are two key things I use my phone for.
Cons:
- Non removable battery. Not a big problem, but is always handy to have.
- It will be more difficult to root and modify the device software which is something I love to do and also have some apps that only work with root access. I'm sure it wont be impossible, but will require more work than the other two.
This is, as i said earlier, all based on leaks and rumours, including the image to the right, but given that many leaks and rumours for the S2 and S3 came to be correct, I'm using them for this post.
Pros:
- 8 core processor in Samsung's new Exynos 5 Octa powerhouse. This is real and already publicised, but unconfirmed that it will be in the S4. I have a feeling they will save it for the Note 3 but either way, it will pave the way for some incredible applications.
- Far easier to root and modify and tends to attract far more home brew developers than other brand devices which leads to some brilliant tools and applications that can make the device even better than Samsung originally intended.
- Removable battery, again not a major issue, but it's nice to have.
- SD card support.
- Better compatibility with my Samsung Smart TV. Although there are many apps that will allow any brand phone or tablet to share and stream content to any brand smart TV, the Samsung Smart TV apps I have on my S3 do tend to work better or have other features that third party ones dont.
Cons:
- The only con I can think of here is design, and material. Samsung is known for using plastic for their flagship devices and I cant see it being any different for the S4. Admittedly its nice, hard wearing plastic, but plastic none the less and although its never been a deal breaker for me in the past, with other brand flagships being built with much higher grade materials such as glass and polycarbonate, plastic is starting to look a bit cheap, especially for a high end product.
HTC One
HTC have developed some possible game changing features for their new One device, which I plan to go over properly in another blog post, for now though I'll keep it simple.
Pros:
- Beats Audio, which I had on my HTC One X last year and the audio quality was far superior than any phone I have ever used before or since, an excellent phone for music.
- Stereo speakers on the front of the device, nice and loud, which means it would be great for watching films and would also eliminate having cup your phone in your hand to boost the sound in order to show someone a YouTube clip.
- Wide angle front facing camera, same as the one on the HTC 8X which comes in handy for those Instagram selfies, making a Skype call to someone with a group of friends or taking an arm length photo of you and your other half.
- No SD card support, which for me is a true deal breaker. I was really excited about this phone, it has some amazing new features including a revolutionary new camera, redesigned Sense UI, and of course the above pro list but for me its a total no-go without an SD card slot. It comes in both 32 and 64 GB models, and although the 64GB would probably be enough for my use, its just easier to transfer data between my phone/tablet/laptop and various other devices with removeable storage and after using the One X for a short while recently while I was waiting on an insurance claim for my Galaxy S3 to be replaced, its something I learnt I just cant live without.
- Non removable battery.
Quite conclusively then, I'm going to opt for the Xperia Z, which launches in the UK on 28th Febuarary. It's a stunning and jam packed device with everything I need in a phone and with the only real downside of being slightly more difficult to root and install custom software than the others.
The HTC One, or M7 as it will be known in Europe will be available from March 15th and the Samsung Galaxy S4 will be unveiled on March 14th at this years Unpacked Event with a rumoured release date around April/May.
Of course these are all Android devices and 2013 has an awful lot to offer besides this with the new BlackBerry Z10, a new range of Windows Phone 8 devices and dedicated Ubuntu devices due later in the year, but at the moment only Android has the feature set and apps I require for day to day use. Your needs may differ but I hope this post goes some way to helping you make an informative choice on your next phone.



I'm so glad you've gone for the Xperia Z, it's an epic handset.
ReplyDeleteOne thing I thought I'd point out in your 'cons' on the Z is that XDA developers released info on the Xperia Z being rooted already - http://www.xda-developers.com/android/sony-xperia-z-rooted-before-release/. Also, regarding the non-removable battery, in my eyes, I see that as a 'pro' point. Let me explain: Removable batteries are classed as "accessories" in the box with the phone, this means that their warranty only lasts for 6 months (much like a hands-free kit bundled with the phone), If the battery is built into the unit, it is therefore PART OF THE PHONE which would automatically mean its warranty is the same as the phone itself, 24 months. So if there are any faults with the battery, you are covered for the life of the contract (if that's the route you choose to go down) and you can always get a rechargeable external battery. I got one from Carphone Warehouse for £20!
Great blog by the way!
Hi, thanks for your great comment. I did check XDA before posting and there wasn't much going on but a day in XDA land is a long time and a lot can happen, I'm glad to see root access made so soon. I did state that it wouldn't be impossible just more difficult, the Galaxy and HTC range tend to get one-click root software made for them and I also remember it being fairly difficult to root my flatmates Sony Tablet S. The only thing that concerns me is unlocking the bootloader means the loss of the Bravia Engine due to DRM so I'm hoping there will be a way to root and re-lock the bootloader after. That's a very good point about the battery, and like I said, its not a huge deal, I however look at it from the view that if something was to go wrong with the battery, the whole phone would need to be sent away for repair instead of just getting a replacement battery which means I could be without it for a week or so. That being said I haven't had a problem with a phone battery for a long time which is why I see it as mainly a non issue these days. I have a Kensington backup micro USB charger and it is a lifesaver at times! Glad you like my new blog, only started last week but I'm seeing good viewing numbers already so I'm happy people are enjoying what I have to say. When I get my Z I will be making a full review here, but I'm not due an upgrade on any of my lines till March 11th so it will be a few days after that. What phone are you enjoying at the moment? I'm thinking of going for the Xperia Z Tablet to replace my old Galaxy Tab too.
Delete